Gathoga and Another v Regina (Criminal Appeal No. 1696 of 1953; Criminal Appeal No. 1699 of 1953) [1953] EACA 13 (1 January 1953)
Court
East African Court of Appeal
Case number
Criminal Appeal No. 1696 of 1953 ; Criminal Appeal No. 1699 of 1953
Judge
De Lestang J, Hearne CJ
The court quashed convictions for membership in an unlawful society, holding that an accused cannot be convicted on irrelevant evidence not accompanied by particulars.
Rex v Kimingi (Criminal Appeal No. 68 of 1947) [1947] EACA 72 (1 January 1947)
Court
East African Court of Appeal
Case number
Criminal Appeal No. 68 of 1947
Judge
De Lestang J, Nihill, C.J
The court found that the evidence did not support a conviction for storebreaking because the appellant provided a plausible and corroborated explanation for his possession of the stolen property, and he was not in exclusive possession. The court further held that it was not permissible to substitute a conviction for receiving stolen property on a charge of storebreaking, as receiving is not a minor offence to storebreaking under section 179(1) of the Criminal Procedure Code, and section 187 only applies to charges of stealing. The precedent in Rex v. Maganbhai Valabhai Patel and Haribhai Apab…